Well thats the problem now, is it? MMOs that goes from a pay-to-play to a free-to-play business model usually goes down because of the sole reason that they cant hold enough players in their game thats why they're forced to transition
An example would be FFXIV, there was rumors of it going F2P but was later squashed due to how its prospering last time I checked
Look at it a financial standpoint, why would a company go F2P when its P2P business model is working; the transition is just not necessary
If it does go F2P it might prosper in the short-run but if they still dont shape up, the game is dead like SWTOR
Dont get me wrong, I am in the same boat as you guys and want the game to be successful but I just can not see that happening the way it is going at the moment.
Just a shot in the dark here but maybe thats why Apoc and the other Buddy Devs are delaying this as much as they can which is completely understandable since you dont wanna work on something and not profit from it in the end.