Your providing a time based service, and not at least pausing our subscription times or extending our subscription the number of days your service is down is unacceptable. As many months as most of us have paid already you cant extend when your product is down?
It doesn't even come down to right or wrong, it comes down to keeping your customers happy. In general with anything subscription based, just like wow, if there is down time your service time will be extended for the duration of the downtime.