So just a bit of an update for you on my journey towards becoming Insane! I have recovered my Bloodsail rep a few thousand into honored. No small feat given that the Faldir’s Cove kills only give you around 5 to 25 xp per kill.
The job was made much easier though through the passive use of Honorbuddy. While I used a bot account to farm kills on one computer, I had my main account (which I do not bot ever) join in a party and so I got all the rep from those kills on my main without actually having to run around killing by hand. I would love to have been able to do this all the way to Exalted, but these mobs stop giving rep one you hit revered.
BTW, for those of you having issues botting this area, I found it easier to simply blackspot the entire pirate ship from top to bottom along with the ramp and area around the ramp to prevent my toon from going inside and getting stuck on occasion. The respawn rate for the pirates outside the ship is fast enough that he was never standing around for more than a few seconds. You do have to keep an eye out for folks in the area doing quests with these npcs. I think I had to stop botting about a half dozen times to let people interact with them to complete things.
I have moved on to getting my Steamwheel Cartel rep back using much the same method as Bloodsail. That is slow going but I will get there eventually. I feel good about getting my Bloodsail back up to honored. I know that there is a good possibility that it is no longer necessary to have it at the same time as Steamwheel for the achievement, I just didn’t want to take the chance. Also, since Steamwheel takes so long to get back, I did not want to have to do it a second time. Bloodsail was much quicker to bot with the 5 to 25 rep per kill than Steamwheel with its 2 to 6 rep per kill. Hey, I also et to have the bloodsail Admiral acheivement on my bot which is a neat plus!
I have now started the long harvest for mats to create my Darkmoon cards for rep turn in and have been making pickpocketing trips to gather the junkboxes needed for Ravenholt. I figure a few strong weeks of gathering and crafting and I should have the title down!
Again, thanks to Klovnene and everyone who has posted in this thread for the ideas, paths and everything else.