Gosh this is a hell of an emotional thread!
I think we can all agree that this probably does make "business sense" from Bossland's perspective. The lifetime keys from their perspective were "zero marginal revenue". They really only had two options if they were in financial strain:
- Shrink to Grow: Cancel the keys and accept whatever upside they get from resubscribing life-time key users (which obviously myself and many other people will not be re-subscribing). Thisis obviously a "dick move" given that people did not get what they paid for and will leave a bad taste in many people's mouths who will not come back - but it at least guarantees SOME revenue upside.
- Drive Growth through Upsell of what would have been sticky lifetime key customers to generate additional revenue through other add-ons. I am guessing this was not an option because all third party developers operate on their own websites (siune, protosynth etc.) because Bossland "missed the party" when they decided not to give third party developers another option through a rebornbuddy store.
Given that they chose option 1 it may be as others have suggested above that this is a company on the brink of destruction just trying to nab whatever revenue it can before the ship sinks - since Option 2 is probably what a company that seriously thought it had growth prospects would be pushing for, particularly if as I suspect, lifetime key users are low to zero marginal cost to serve. Interesting to see how it all pans out!
Huge issue with the bot itself and the pricing is that in order to get any kind of real use out of the bot, you have to basically subscribe to 3/4 other addons. Mew being the only one that isn't a monthly sub as well.
I can't tell if we just have some rich kids spending their parents cash or what, but when I see people making these, 'oh well give them a break guys, this bot is so good' I can't tell if it's the actual bossland people under aliases trying to calm everyone down, or just people spending their parents money that don't want to rock the boat.
If you really want to get the most out of the bot, and aren't capable of writing your own xmls for every task, you're basically having to pay for a CR monthly, a crafting bot monthly, a one time fee gathering bot that might go monthly. This leaves out the other side niche options like Eureka, Dungeon Master, MGP farming, etc.
I mean you have to pay fucking upwards of 50-70 dollars a month for the bot, it makes no fucking sense. If the price of the monthly base bot wasn't so high, whatever, but the fact it's fucking 15 itself. Shows they're really out of touch with what the bot does, or how the users are using the bot. The lifetime key removal took their only good free CR and ended it, and the people that typically make orderbot profiles have their own pay options. This also isn't mentioning compared to the other bots it takes forever to get working after the patches for the most part, the loss of gil alone due to the downtime is staggering.
Not a great situation, and due to the whole killing of lifetime fees, on top of how it was done leads me to have the same worries as you tichy. The fact they didn't have enough revenue suggests most of the users were from when lifetime was a thing, or they're just really fucking desperate for money. I'd be curious to see the numbers as to how many were grandfathered in lifetimers vs post lt monthly users.