Hi,
I was extremely concerned about other players' reporting me -just as you are.
Some experience three aspets (1) Gathering, (2) Questing and (3) Grinding:
TL
R --'Gathering' profiles: monitor a full cycle for blackspots, then low monitoring ok; questing: low montoring ok; Grinding: constant attention.
1.) GATHERING -- The bots are extremely good, but do need monitoring --at least at first. For example, I use AutoAngler2 (Botbase) to fish in Valley of the Four Winds; now by itself the Profile (by Gatherit) is awesome, it was 99% accurate --never getting stuck --but it did get stuck 100% every time on *one spot*. If I wasn't monitoring its first usage [the first few hours] I wouldn't have been able to spot the one bad 'blackspot' and tweak the .XML profile [myself] and permanently add an exception. Now I've done that I can be confident that my bot will not get stuck there again and I successfuly (though with some anxiety!) leave him overnight. This process has been applied to all of my gathering routines, as sure enough, there is one bad blackspot in an entire zone that needs tweaking. *The consequence* of not fixing that blackspot --my character was left 'jumping' stationary in the water, 5 yards away from a embankment he could walk up) --left me looking very bot like indeed! I'm sure if that I saw that myself I would instantly think 'bot'.
2.) QUESTING -- As for questing, I use Kick's profile and so far my only problem has been that some quests need manual intervention (like looting certain mobs, mechanics involving vehicles -etc). The character looks quite organic to be honest, at all times. When the Profile breaks down (as said, the Profile won't finish a quest) your character stays 'organic'; you won't end up running in a circle but rather run around killing mobs... and maybe progress your quest(s) albeit at a slower rate, but you don't look like a bot -you look like you're working on quests.
3.) GRINDING -- I would say, that Grinding bots and Profiles (acting in Pandaria) require the most monitoring. I've seen in the last 24 hours three call outs on /1 General Channel (with coordinates) to name and shame 'botters'. Out of curisoity I went to investigate and yeah, this 87 was grinding away on these mobs and it looked terrible. What ever bot, profile and combat routine this guy was using: it was shamefully obvious he was a bot. I am sure the profiles and Grinding botbase(s?) in HonorBuddy are more convincing than the happless idiot I saw in Valley of the Four Winds, but it did make me consider the risks and attention you draw from grinding in Pandaria for *any* amount of time -5 hours or 5 minutes, personally I would be monitoring.