Ok, here are my thoughts:
Questbot works great, you can solo 1-90 AFK. If any problems appear, thats because of profile issues or game bugs. We do not need anything new for questing, because the weak point are the profiles. Not exactly the profiles, its because blizz sometimes changes quests around and the profiles are not 100% up to date.
Any other quest bot would have the exact same problems! So a new questbot would not change that!!!
I leveled 10 toons 1-90 with questing, 95% AFK. No ban.
Gathering: Why would we need another botbase for that? There are a few and they all work and are not detected or anything. You cannot gather faster with another botbase. You cannot gather safer with another botbase.
Ofc you need some plugins to avoid other players, because the bans happen because of reports by other players or gathering too much or flooding the ah. If noone sees you gathering, noone will report you. If you don`t gather 24/7 and spam the ah nothing will happen. So we don`t need that, because it would not solve any of these problems.
RAF:
Yes that would be nice. But I think that could be solved with an plugin. I already explained my Idea a while ago.
All chars run the same questing profile. Everytime a quest gets turned it, the plugin pauses the bot before finishing to turn in the quest and waits untill all party members are doing the same. That way all partymembers would always meet at the quest turn in and gain the XP bonus. Because they are all starting the quest at the same time, they will be in range of eachother 90% of the time. For that both bots need to communicate with eachother. It qould be awesome if that cold be done eaven if both bots are running on different computes.
Not like on botanists raf dungeon profiles where the booster just waits untill everyone is in range, no it sould be done using a real connection between the bot computers and both really communicating with eachoter.
There is one problem with the avalible RAF solutions: If one party member takes a flightpath, its messed up.
If one partymember loots an questitem and turns it in, while the other one didn`t loot the item yet, its messed up.
In my oppinion the most important bot atm
Battlegrounds The BGbuddy is a ban catcher, because the bot acts totally stupid, the paths are not random at all, I personally can detect 9 of 10 Bots before the bg begins. ATM it is a absolutely wothless piece of shit
The Profiles for the Bgs are crap and cannot be changed! I would love to have a BG Bot where users can create custom Profiles and have an option to randomly load up these profiles.
BGS are flooded with bots and all do the same shit all the time. If Blizz wants to bann bots, this is the fastest way to start a banwave! Just take some GMs, explain them 10 minutes how to detect a bot in a BG and they can ban hundrets of bots in 1h each! And because of what? Because of the stupid BGBuddy
BUT I am strictly against an arena bot.
Why? For the same reason HB didn`t release an arena bot. That would influence the gameplay for other players too much and would enormously piss off blizz. And the reaction would be a much heavier ban behavior. Because atm they kind of tolerate bots. Ok they ban them of course, but not as much as they could do if they wanted to. If they would employ me, I could easylie detect 100 Bots a day on my realm.... They also can, but since they also pay for their gametime they don`t ban unless they get reported or they just ban some to pretend they are doing something against bots.
But an arena bot would piss so many arena players off, that blizz has to react real hard and start an real offensive against botting.
A lot of players report bots atm.
There are already bans of main accounts just using combat routines in arena and not using any other bots. Arena players take that very serious. So please never make a bot like that, it will destroy botting!
-And hell yeah, if you want money for it, I am willing to pay it. I already invested in UltimatePvP suite qith the hope to make bgbuddy better by using it. And yes, it helped but it does not solve the major problems of bgbuddy. I have so many toons I would love to do pvp with but there is no way of collecting honor without the extremely hight risk of getting banned.