If I'm reading what you wrote correctly, I think I see why you're struggling. You come on here and read something that's working for someone and then you attempt to duplicate it yourself. It may work, but only somewhat... so you then look for something else.
Rather than jump on the obsidium shuffle or other ideas from these forums, you need to shut down the bot and do some research. Yes, it takes time - Yes, it isn't as much fun or as easy as finding the magic method, but the reality is, what works on one server MAY work on another... but if you do the research, then you can find what works - or at least what is working at the time. By spending the time to research you will be able to open up multiple methods that work - so when one starts to tank, you focus on the others while you do more research...
Again, I'm just suggesting on what I read in your post. If I'm off-base, then I appologize...
Have a great day!